JavaScript seems to be disabled in your browser.

You must have JavaScript enabled in your browser to utilize the functionality of this website. Click here for instructions on enabling javascript in your browser.

Blue Gate Bakery specialties are Amish made, customer favorites. From our sweet homemade Amish Peanut Butter to the Old Fashioned Homemade Amish Noodles. Find your Blue Gate Restaurant and Bakery favorites here and bring the taste of Shipshewana home with you.
Result Pages:
View:
Amish Peanut Butter Spread - 08 fl oz


$4.99

Our famous Old Fashioned Amish Peanut Butter Spread, made with our own secret recipe. This is the same Old Fashioned Amish Peanut Butter Spread that we serve in the Blue Gate Restaurant.…

$4.99
Amish Peanut Butter Spread - 16 fl oz


$5.99

Our famous Old Fashioned Amish Peanut Butter Spread, made with our own secret recipe. This is the same Old Fashioned Amish Peanut Butter Spread that we serve in the Blue Gate Restaurant.…

$5.99
Apple Butter - 08 fl oz


$2.99

Made in the Heart of Amish Country. Get a little bit of the Simple Life shipped right to your door!…

$2.99
Apple Butter - 12 fl oz


$3.99

Made in the Heart of Amish Country. Get a little bit of the Simple Life shipped right to your door!…

$3.99


$4.99

Apple Butter - 32 fl oz…

$4.99
Cashew Crunch


$6.29

Blue Gate Cashew Crunch - Absolutely addictive, softer than peanut brittle and a melt in your mouth taste that will make you order more!…

$6.29
Fine Homestyle Noodles - 16 oz - DISC 12/2


$3.59

Old-Fashioned Homemade Noodles just like the local Amish serve at home. This is the thin noodle, the best for mixing with other ingredients and thin sauces. Try them in a chicken-n-noodles recipe, mixed with vegetables or greens straight from the garden or mixed with a flavorful thin gravy or sauce...…

$3.59
French Dressing - 1 Pint


$5.99

French Dressing - 1 Pint…

$5.99
Honey Mustard Dressing - 1 Pint


$5.99

Honey Mustard Dressing - 1 Pint…

$5.99
Medium Homestyle Noodles - 16 oz


$3.59

Old-Fashioned Homemade Noodles just like the local Amish serve at home. This is the medium noodle, extremely versatile, great for chicken-n-noodles recipes, as an entree with a hearty fresh from the garden sauce or as a side smothered in Mom's homemade gravy...…

$3.59
Wide Homestyle Noodles - 16 oz


$3.59

Old-Fashioned Homemade Noodles just like the local Amish serve at home. This is the wide noodle, hearty and filling, great for a chicken-n-noodles recipe, stroganoff or smothered in Mom's homemade gravy...…

$3.59
Result Pages: