JavaScript seems to be disabled in your browser.

You must have JavaScript enabled in your browser to utilize the functionality of this website. Click here for instructions on enabling javascript in your browser.

Blue Gate Pies can now be shipped!! A selection of our handmade Amish pies are available for purchase online and shipping directly to your home. Handmade with the best ingredients, these pies are sure to be a favorite!
Result Pages:
View:
Apple Pie


$12.99

Whole Pie…

$12.99
Blueberry Pie


$12.99

Whole Pie…

$12.99
Cherry Crumb Pie


$12.99

Full Pie…

$12.99
Cherry Pie


$12.99

Whole Pie…

$12.99
Coconut Custard Pie


$12.99

Whole Pie Half Pie Also available Seasonal…

$12.99
Custard Pie


$12.99

Whole Pie Seasonal…

$12.99
Dutch Apple Pie - Whole


$12.99

Dutch Apple Pie - Whole…

$12.99
German Chocolate Pie - Whole


$13.49

German Chocolate Pie - Whole…

$13.49
Old Fashion Cream Pie


$12.99

Whole Pie Seasonal…

$12.99
Peach Pie


$12.99

Whole Pie…

$12.99
Pecan Pie - Whole


$13.49

Pecan Pie - Whole…

$13.49
Sugar Free Apple Pie


$12.99

Whole Pie…

$12.99
Result Pages: