JavaScript seems to be disabled in your browser.

You must have JavaScript enabled in your browser to utilize the functionality of this website. Click here for instructions on enabling javascript in your browser.

Result Pages:
View:
Apple Butter 12oz (Case)


$54.99

Our famous Old Fashioned Apple Butter, made in the Heart of Amish Country. This is the same Old Fashioned Apple Butter that we serve in the Blue Gate Restaurant. Get a little bit of the Simple Life shipped right to your door! This case includes 12 - 12oz jars.…

$54.99
Apple Butter Half-Pints (Case)


$43.99

Our famous Old Fashioned Apple Butter, made in the Heart of Amish Country. This is the same Old Fashioned Apple Butter that we serve in the Blue Gate Restaurant. Get a little bit of the Simple Life shipped right to your door! This case includes 12 half-pint jars.…

$43.99
Peanut Butter Half-Pints (Case)


$54.99

Our famous Old Fashioned Amish Peanut Butter, made with our own secret recipe. This is the same Old Fashioned Amish Peanut Butter that we serve in the Blue Gate Restaurant. This case includes 12 half-pint jars.…

$54.99
Peanut Butter Pints (Case)


$65.99

Our famous Old Fashioned Amish Peanut Butter, made with our own secret recipe. This is the same Old Fashioned Amish Peanut Butter that we serve in the Blue Gate Restaurant. This case includes 12 pint jars.…

$65.99
Result Pages: