JavaScript seems to be disabled in your browser.

You must have JavaScript enabled in your browser to utilize the functionality of this website. Click here for instructions on enabling javascript in your browser.

Amish made jams and jellies from the Blue Gate in Shipshewana are a must-have for your kitchen. Your favorite Blue Gate spreads are made with the best ingredients and sealed for freshness.
Result Pages:
View:
Amish Peanut Butter Spread


$4.99

Our famous Old Fashioned Amish Peanut Butter Spread, made with our own secret recipe. This is the same Old Fashioned Amish Peanut Butter Spread that we serve in the Blue Gate Restaurant. Ingredients: Peanut butter, Blue Gate syrup, corn syrup, marshmallow cream …

$4.99
Apple Butter


$2.99

Made in the Heart of Amish Country. Get a little bit of the Simple Life shipped right to your door! Ingredients: Apples, cider and or concentrate, sugar, corn syrup, cinnamon, allspices…

$2.99
Apple Pie Filling - 32oz


$6.99

Apple pie filling for an 8 inch pie pan. Ingredients: water, sugar, apples, Perma-Flo, cinnamon …

$6.99
Apricot Jam


$3.99

Apricot Jam - Available in 16 fl oz or 8 fl oz Enjoy our vibrant and fresh Apricot Jam. Great with a slice of toast or try it as a glaze on a chicken or pork dish! Ingredients: apricots, sugar, pectin, butter, & lemon juice. …

$3.99
Berry Patch Jam


$3.99

Blue Gate Berry Patch Jam - Available in 16 fl oz and 8 fl oz This jar of berries features a marvelous blend of raspberries, blueberries, blackberries and strawberries. Spread it on toast, pancakes, waffles and anything else you want to add some fresh fruit flavor to. Ingredients: strawberries, blueberries, raspberries, blackberries, pectin, sugar, butter & lemon juice. …

$3.99
Blackberry Jam


$3.99

Blackberry Jam - Available in 16 fl oz and 8 fl oz Using the ripest, juiciest blackberries and a touch of sugar, this wonderfully light and tasty jam is great on muffins, toast, in hot cereal or on a peanut butter sandwich. Ingredients: black raspberries, pectin, sugar, butter & lemon juice. …

$3.99
Blueberry Jam


$3.99

Blueberry Jam - Available in 16 fl oz and 8 fl oz The natural sweetness, brilliant blue color and fresh taste make these jams ideal for savoring on its own or as an ingredient for boldly flavored recipes like blueberry muffins. Ingredients: blueberries, pectin, lemon juice, sugar & butter…

$3.99
Cherry Jam


$3.99

Cherry Jam - Available in 16 fl oz and 8 fl oz Our cherry jam packs the delicious tastes of cherries into a simple spread. The jam is naturally sweet with the flavor of ripe cherries. Enjoy this cherry jam over bread, toast, pancakes, and more. You can even add it to your baking for a boost of fruity goodness. Ingredients: cherries, sugar, pectin & butter …

$3.99
Cherry Rhubarb Jam


$3.99

Cherry Rhubarb Jam - Comes in 16 fl oz and 8 fl oz The perfect blend of cherry and rhubarb to create a sweet jelly. Perfect on toast or to top off an Ice Cream Sunday Ingredients: sugar, rhubarb, cherry pie filling, water, jello…

$3.99
Dutch Apple Jam


$3.99

Dutch Apple Jam - Available in 16 fl oz and 8 fl oz The perfect blend of spices and apples that give you the warm homemade feelings. With natural pieces of apple making it the right kind of texture for any kind of meal. Ingredients: apples, sugar, brown sugar, pectin, water & spices…

$3.99
Hot Pepper Jam


$3.99

Hot Pepper Jam - Available in 16 fl oz and 8 fl oz We’re loving this different kind of jam, ripe and juicy with a lasting kick. It’s pale red, speckled with seeds, and just sweet enough to subdue the spice. Great for adding to any entrée. Ingredients: red peppers, green peppers, jalapeno peppers, vinegar, pectin & sugar …

$3.99
Peach Jam


$3.99

Peach Jam - Available in 16 fl oz and 8 fl oz This is one of our Old Fashioned delights made from our own fresh pureed Peaches. Great for Sunday Brunch and will remind you of the delicious flavors of summer. Ingredients: peaches, sugar, lemon juice, pectin & butter…

$3.99
Peach Pie Filling - 32oz


$6.99

Peach pie filling for an 8 inch pie pan. Ingredients: water, sugar, peaches, Perma-Flo, gelatin, lemon juice …

$6.99
Peach Pineapple Jam - 8 fl oz


$3.99

Peach Pineapple Jam - 8 fl oz The perfect summer jam that's bursting with flavor. Great for putting on toast or adding to any Ice Cream Sunday. A great way to enjoy any hot summer day Ingredients: sugar, pineapple, peaches, pectin, water, lemon juice…

$3.99
Raspberry Pie Filling - 32 oz


$7.99

Raspberry pie filling for an 8 inch pie pan. Ingredients: water, red raspberries, sugar, Perma-Flo, Jello, almond, salt …

$7.99
Red Raspberry Jalapeno Jam


$3.99

Red Raspberry Jalapeno Jam - Available in 16 fl oz and 8 fl oz Sweet with a little kick, most preferer to put this out as an appetizer spread, but still would be great for Sunday Brunch. The sweet red raspberries help to curve the kick of the jalapenos to make it the perfect combinations of sweet and spicy. Ingredients: sugar, raspberries, jalapenos, pectin, water …

$3.99
Red Raspberry Jam w/ Seeds


$3.99

Red Raspberry Jam w/ Seeds - Available in 16 fl oz and 8 fl oz Our organic, homestyle raspberry jam is made with sun-ripened red raspberries that are simmered to perfection, then cooled to create a luscious, antioxidant-rich preserve. With no high fructose corn syrup, the wholesome fruit flavor of our raspberry jam really shines through. Ingredients: red raspberries, sugar, pectin, butter & lemon juice…

$3.99
Rhubarb Jam


$3.99

Rhubarb Jam - Available in 16 fl oz and 8 fl oz Enjoy the fresh tart taste of our Rhubarb Jam perfect for any summer occasion. Spread it over warm bread or add to any sweet dessert. Ingredients: rhubarb, sugar, pineapple, gelatin, butter & citric acid …

$3.99
Seedless Black Raspberry Jam


$4.99

Seedless Black Raspberry Jam Our homemade jam bursting with the intense flavors and expertly strained for no seeds left. Try it on toast or any breakfast dish.…

$4.99
Seedless Red Raspberry Jam


$4.99

Seedless Red Raspberry Jam - Available in 16 fl oz and 8 fl oz Ingredients: red raspberries, sugar, pectin, butter & lemon juice…

$4.99
Strawberry Jam


$3.99

Strawberry Jam - Available in 16 fl oz and 8 fl oz Our fresh strawberry jam is sure to bring smiles to any table. Great by itself or added to any dish to add a touch of sweet summertime to it. Ingredients: strawberries, sugar, pectin, lemon juice & butter …

$3.99
Strawberry Rhubarb Jam


$3.99

Strawberry Rhubarb Jam The perfect blend of sweet and tart. One of our favorites, can be added to any breakfast meal or snack time cravings. Ingredients: strawberries, rhubarb, pineapple, sugar, gelatin, butter & lemon juice …

$3.99
Result Pages: