JavaScript seems to be disabled in your browser.

You must have JavaScript enabled in your browser to utilize the functionality of this website. Click here for instructions on enabling javascript in your browser.

Freshly baked, Amish made cookies. Our assortment of Amish made cookies and dessert bars use only the finest ingredients for the best flavors. From the classic Chocolate Chip cookie to the rich Chocolate Crinkle, there is a cookie or dessert bar for everyone.
Result Pages:
View:
Assorted Cookie Platter


$21.99

Delicious Blue Gate assorted cookie platter.
A sample of all our Christams favorites including:
Chocolate Crinkle, Cranberry Oatmeal, Chocolate Chip, Sugar Sprinkle, Russian Tea Cookies and Pecan Tassies.

Customize a platter with all your favorites!
Call the Bakery at 260.768.4725, we'll put it together and ship!

Additional Options: Monster Cookies, Sugar Cookies, Lemon Crinkle Cookies, Molasses Cookies, Peanut Butter Cookies, Maple Iced Cookies, Peanut Butter-Chocolate Kiss Cookies and Snicker Doodles.…

$21.99
Carrot Cake Bars - 8x8 pan


$7.99

Carrot Cake Bars - 8x8 pan…

$7.99
Chocolate Chip Cookies


$6.49

Delight in this all-time favorite cookie. Packed full of chocolate chips, this cookie will be gone in a hurry! Ingredients: Enriched wheat flour, eggs, butter, sugar, brown sugar, vanilla, soda, salt, chocolate chips Made in a facility that uses peanuts…

$6.49
Chocolate Crinkle Cookies


$6.49

Gooey cocoa batter peeks through mounds of powdered sugar to satisfy the pickiest chocolate lover! Ingredients: Enriched wheat flour, sugar, eggs, vegetable oil, cocoa, vanilla, salt, baking powder Made in a facility that uses peanuts…

$6.49
Cranberry Oatmeal Cookies


$6.49

Soft, chewy cookies packed full with raisins, oatmeal, and cranberries. These will for sure delight anyone who tries them! Available in 1/2 Dozen increments. Ingredients: Enriched wheat flour, oatmeal, butter, shortening, sugar, brown sugar, cranberries, soda, vanilla, salt, baking powder, nutmeg, milk, eggs Made in a facility that uses peanuts, tree nuts, soy, dairy…

$6.49
Double Chocolate Brownies


$7.99

One Pan of Brownies These gooey delicious brownies are a favorite among families. With their rich chocolate batter topped with our chocolate icing. …

$7.99
German Chocolate Bars


$7.99

Fall in love with these chewy chocolate cookies layer and topped with gooey homemade German chocolate coconut frosting. Ingredients: sugar, flour, vegetable shortening, soybean oil, corn syrup, coconut, cocoa, eggs, salt, pecans. Made in a facility that uses peanuts. …

$7.99
Iced Sugar Cookies


$7.49

This soft, light cookie is made with soft and buttery buttermilk and slight traces of lemon and topped with a delicious homemade caramel icing. Sure to make your mouth water!…

$7.49
Lemon Crinkle Cookies


$6.49

These soft and chewy cookies are bursting with lemon flavor. With just a slight tart taste of lemon and the sweetness of the powdered sugar is sure to make you want more than just one! Available in 1/2 dozen increments Ingredients: Enriched wheat flour, sugar, eggs, vegetable oil, lemon flavor, vanilla, salt, baking powder Made in a facility that uses peanuts…

$6.49
Molasses Cookies


$6.49

Fall in love with our tender molasses cookie with sweet spices of cinnamon and nutmeg and complimenting flavor of the spicy ginger. Sprinkled with large granulated sugar to make them just as beautiful as they are delicious. Available in 1/2 Dozen increments. Ingredients: Brown sugar, sugar, molasses, shortening, sour milk, eggs, baking powder, soda, vanilla, flour Made in a facility that uses peanuts…

$6.49
Monster Cookies


$6.49

The scrumptious taste of these cookies will take you back home... chewy cookie filled with chocolate chips, M&M's, oatmeal and peanut butter. Yum! Each box contains 6 cookies.…

$6.49
Oatmeal Raisin Cookies


$6.49

There's nothing quite our batch of homemade old fashioned Oatmeal Cookies, just like Grandma made! They're soft and chewy, perfectly spiced, dotted with juicy raisins and crunchy walnuts and always sure to satisfy those cookie cravings. Available in 1/2 Dozen increments. Ingredients: Enriched flour, oatmeal, butter, shortening, sugar, brown sugar, raisins, soda, vanilla, salt, baking powder, nutmeg, cinnamon, milk, eggs …

$6.49
Peanut Butter Cookies


$6.49

Available in 1/2 Dozen increments. These gooey cookies that are filled with decadent peanut butter flavor. Sure to be a new favorite for anyone who bites into them Ingredients: enriched wheat flour, sugar, brown sugar, peanut butter, butter, eggs, vanilla, baking powder, salt. CONTAINS PEANUTS. …

$6.49


$7.99

Pumkpin Bars…

$7.99
Pumpkin Roll


$8.99

Spices and pumpkin form a cake-like batter topped with cream cheese icing, then rolled up and topped with more cream cheese icing. The sweetest treat for any occasion, all year long! 13 ounces Ingredients: Sugar, all-purpose flour, pumpkin, eggs, cinnamon, ginger, lemon juice, baking powder, nutmeg, salt. Frosting: Powder sugar, cream cheese, butter, vanilla Made in a facility that uses peanuts.…

$8.99
Snickerdoodle Cookies


$6.49

Available in 1/2 Dozen increments. This classic cinnamon flavored, soft and chewy cookie is made with real butter, brown sugar, wheat flour, fresh eggs and just the right amount of cinnamon. Ingredients: Enriched wheat flour, sugar, eggs, butter, shortening, brown sugar, cinnamon, cream of tartar, baking soda, salt Made in a facility that uses peanuts…

$6.49
Sugar Cookies


$6.49

Our sugar cookies have a rich buttery taste and a soft chewy center each cookie is topped with colorful sugar. Perfect for a sweet snack or any event. Available in 1/2 Dozen increments. Ingredients: Enriched wheat flour, eggs, sugar, vegetable oil, vanilla, baking powder, baking soda, buttermilk, lemon Made in facility that uses peanuts…

$6.49
Whoopie Pie


$1.99

Who can resist soft chocolate sandwich cookies filled with a layer of fluffy frosting? These scrumptious chocolate whoopie pies are made with two soft and fluffy chocolate cake rounds and a layer of creamy vanilla frosting sandwiched in between. Comes with vanilla frosting or peanut butter frosting. Ingredients: sugar, flour, shortening, water, milk, eggs, vinegar, vanilla, baking powder, salt, egg whites, mint extract, brown sugar, cream of tartar, corn syrup, vanilla, soda, salt, cocoa, vegetable oil, powdered sugar Allergens: milk, soy, wheat, egg. Made in a facility that uses peanuts. …

$1.99
Result Pages: