JavaScript seems to be disabled in your browser.

You must have JavaScript enabled in your browser to utilize the functionality of this website. Click here for instructions on enabling javascript in your browser.

Freshly baked, Amish made cookies. Our assortment of Amish made cookies and dessert bars use only the finest ingredients for the best flavors. From the classic Chocolate Chip cookie to the rich Chocolate Crinkle, there is a cookie or dessert bar for everyone.
Pumpkin Roll has been added to your Cart
Result Pages:
View:
Assorted Cookie Platter


$19.99

Delicious Blue Gate assorted cookie platter.
A sample of all our Christams favorites including:
Chocolate Crinkle, Cranberry Oatmeal, Chocolate Chip, Sugar Sprinkle, Russian Tea Cookies and Pecan Tassies.

Customize a platter with all your favorites!
Call the Bakery at 888.447.4725, we'll put it together and ship!

Additional Options: Monster Cookies, Sugar Cookies, Lemon Crinkle Cookies, Molasses Cookies, Peanut Butter Cookies, Maple Iced Cookies, Peanut Butter-Chocolate Kiss Cookies and Snicker Doodles.…

$19.99


$5.49

Available in 1 Dozen increments.…

$5.49
Carrot Cake Bars - 8x8 pan


$5.99

Carrot Cake Bars - 8x8 pan…

$5.99
Chocolate Brownies


$5.99

One Pan of Brownies…

$5.99
Chocolate Chip Cookies


$5.49

Delight in this all-time favorite cookie. Packed full of chocolate chips, this cookie will be gone in a hurry! Each box contains 6 cookies.…

$5.49
Chocolate Crinkle Cookies


$5.49

Gooey cocoa batter peeks through mounds of powdered sugar to satisfy the pickiest chocolate lover! Each box contains 6 cookies.…

$5.49
Cranberry Oatmeal Cookies


$5.49

Available in 1/2 Dozen increments.…

$5.49
Maple Iced Cookies


$6.49

Available in 1/2 dozen increments Seasonal…

$6.49
Molasses Cookies


$5.49

Available in 1/2 Dozen increments.…

$5.49
Monster Cookies


$5.49

The scrumptious taste of these cookies will take you back home... chewy cookie filled with chocolate chips, M&M's, oatmeal and peanut butter. Yum! Each box contains 6 cookies.…

$5.49
Peanut Butter Cookies


$5.49

Available in 1/2 Dozen increments.…

$5.49


$5.99

$5.99
Pumpkin Roll


$7.99

Spices and pumpkin form a cake-like batter topped with cream cheese icing, then rolled up and topped with more cream cheese icing. The sweetest treat for any occasion, all year long!…

$7.99
Snickerdoodle Cookies


$5.49

Available in 1/2 Dozen increments.…

$5.49


$5.49

Available in 1/2 Dozen increments.…

$5.49
Result Pages: